1
Marine and Fishery sciences 39 (2): xxx-xxx (2026)
https://doi.org/10.47193/mas.3922026010403
ABSTRACT. The shing footprint, which reects humanity’s demand on marine ecosystems and
is closely linked to sheries sustainability, serves as the main environmental indicator for marine
resources. This study investigated the role of schooling as an indicator of human capital in shaping
the shing footprint in Greece over the period 1990-2022. The empirical analysis employed the
Augmented ARDL (AARDL) approach, concentrating on the potential nonlinear relationship between
human capital and environmental degradation in shing grounds. The ndings reveal the threshold
effects of schooling: while lower levels of human capital increase environmental pressure, once a
certain threshold is surpassed, human capital contributes to reducing environmental degradation in
sheries. Furthermore, the results validate the Environmental Kuznets Curve (EKC) and Environmental
Phillips Curve (EPC) hypotheses in the context of shing grounds.
Key words: Human capital, shing footprint, AARDL.
El papel de la escolarización en la conguración de la huella pesquera en Grecia: evidencia
de un enfoque ARDL aumentado
RESUMEN. La huella pesquera, que reeja la demanda humana sobre los ecosistemas marinos y
está estrechamente vinculada a la sostenibilidad de la pesca, constituye el principal indicador ambiental
de los recursos marinos. Este estudio investigó el papel de la escolarización en la conguración de
la huella pesquera en Grecia durante el período 1990-2022. El análisis empírico empleó el enfoque
ARDL Aumentado (AARDL), centrándose en la posible relación no lineal entre el capital humano y la
degradación ambiental en las zonas pesqueras. Los hallazgos revelan los efectos umbral de la escola-
rización: si bien niveles bajos de capital humano incrementan la presión ambiental, una vez superado
cierto umbral, el capital humano contribuye a reducir la degradación ambiental en la pesca. Además,
los resultados validan las hipótesis de la Curva Ambiental de Kuznets (EKC) y la Curva Ambiental de
Phillips (EPC) en el contexto de las zonas pesqueras.
Palabras clave: Capital humano, huella pesquera, AARDL.
INTRODUCTION
Oceans are fundamental regulators of the Earth’s climate system, absorb-
ing heat and carbon while redistributing energy across the globe (Bigg et al.
ORIGINAL RESEARCH
The role of schooling in shaping the shing footprint in Greece: evidence
from an augmented ARDL approach
Pinar Karahan-dursun1, *, Serkan Şengül1 and Şerif Canbay2
1Department of Economics and Finance, Mudanya University, Bursa, Türkiye. 2Department of Economics, Düzce University, Düzce, Türkiye.
ORCID Pınar Karahan-Dursun https://orcid.org/0000-0002-8289-6570, Serkan Şengül https://orcid.org/0000-0001-9891-9477,
Şerif Canbay https://orcid.org/0000-0001-6141-7510
Marine and
Fishery Sciences
MAFIS
*Correspondence:
pinarkarahan.dursun@mudanya.edu.tr
Received: 23 October 2025
Accepted: 9 December 2025
ISSN 2683-7595 (print)
ISSN 2683-7951 (online)
https://ojs.inidep.edu.ar
Journal of the Instituto Nacional de
Investigación y Desarrollo Pesquero
(INIDEP)
This work is licensed under a Creative
Commons Attribution-
NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0
International License
Marine and Fishery sciences 39 (2): xxx-xxx (2026)
2
2003). The ocean helps regulate the Earth’s climate
by absorbing roughly 25% of human-induced CO2
emissions annually. Moreover, the ocean retains
nearly 90% of the surplus heat captured by green-
house gases, functioning as the Earth’s main heat
reservoir (UN 2025). Yet, growing levels of pollu-
tion undermine these crucial ecological functions.
Ocean pollution is a complex mix of plastics, heavy
metals, agrochemicals, and industrial wastes that
threatens both ecosystems and human health. Mi-
croplastics, mercury, and persistent organic pollut-
ants not only disrupt the ocean’s ability to sequester
carbon but also enter marine food webs, weakening
biodiversity and increasing health risks for humans
(Landrigan et al. 2020).
These ecological threats are particularly notewor-
thy given the heavy reliance of societies on sher-
ies for food and employment. The sheries sector
provides signicant employment opportunities and
supports the livelihoods of many coastal popula-
tions. In 2022, approximately 62 million people
were employed in the sheries sector, and aquatic
animal foods contributed at least 20% of animal
protein intake for about 40% of the global popu-
lation (FAO 2024). Accordingly, ensuring marine
sustainability is crucial for maintaining the continu-
ity of food supply and fostering economic stability.
Within this global context, Greece provides a
particularly meaningful and analytically relevant
case study for examining the human capital-ma-
rine sustainability nexus. Surrounded by the Aegean
and Ionian Seas, Greece possesses one of the most
extensive coastlines in Europe and hosts a high-
ly diverse marine ecosystem that is economically,
socially, and culturally signicant. The Greek sh-
eries and aquaculture sector constitutes a critical
component of the national blue economy: it sup-
ports thousands of small-scale shing communities,
contributes to regional development, and supplies
a major share of the domestic seafood market. Ac-
cording to the World Bank (2025), total sheries
production in Greece grew by 20.6% over the last
decade, reaching 207.502 t in 2022. In the same
year, approximately 23,400 people were employed
in the sector, highlighting its socio-economic im-
portance. Furthermore, as a country with numerous
islands, sheries have historically served as both a
way of life and a primary source of local livelihoods.
Greece also holds a dominant position within the
European Union’s aquaculture industry, accounting
for around half of all farmed sh production among
EU member states in 2022 (FAO 2025).
At the same time, Greece faces structural chal-
lenges directly linked to human capital, including
an aging shing workforce, insufcient environ-
mental training, limited technological moderniza-
tion, and disparities in skills across coastal regions.
These characteristics make Greece an ideal empir-
ical setting to explore how increases in education
and capacity-building may inuence environmental
pressure on marine ecosystems. The combination
of ecological vulnerability, strong socio-economic
dependence on sheries, and clear human capital
constraints offers a coherent motivation for select-
ing Greece as a case study and allows the ndings
to contribute meaningfully both to national policy
debates and to broader Mediterranean and small-
scale sheries contexts facing similar challenges.
Humanity’s demand for marine water ecosys-
tems is represented by the shing grounds footprint,
which is one of the components of the ecological
footprint. Moreover, shing grounds footprint is as-
sociated with sustainability development (Solarin et
al. 2021). The 17th Sustainable Development Goal
incorporates the conservation and sustainable utili-
zation of marine resources for achieving sustainable
development (UN 2025). The shing grounds foot-
print is calculated based on the estimated maximum
sustainable catch of various sh species. These es-
timates are converted into an equivalent primary
production mass according to the trophic levels of
the species and then allocated across the world’s
continental shelf areas (GFN 2025).
The aim of the study was to investigate the im-
pact of human capital on the shing footprint in
Greece over the period 1990-2022. Human activi-
ties represent an important driver of environmental
quality, as education is essential for enabling soci-
Karahan-Dursun et al.: the role of schooling in shaping the fishing footprint in greece 3
eties to comprehend environmental risks1 (Danish
et al. 2019). In addition, nations with higher human
capital tend to possess skills that facilitate the adop-
tion of advanced and cleaner technologies, thereby
contributing to the mitigation of environmental
degradation (Sapkota and Bastola 2017). There
is a growing body of research on the relationship
between human capital and environmental quality
(Balaguer and Cantavella 2018; Ulucak and Bilgili
2018; Danish et al. 2019; Ahmet et al. 2020a, 2020b;
Khan 2020; Çakar et al. 2021; Ganda 2022; Çağlar
et al. 2024; Çamkaya and Karaaslan 2024; Akadiri
et al. 2025). However, studies addressing the role of
human capital in the shing footprint remain very
scarce (Yıldırım et al. 2022; Ayad 2023; Alsaleh et
al. 2024; Ayad et al. 2024; Teng et al. 2024).
This paper sought to ll this gap by investigating
exponential effects of human capital on the shing
footprint for Greece, while controlling for the role
of economic growth. Analyzing exponential effects
enables us to go beyond the binary question of
whether human capital reduces or increases envi-
ronmental degradation for shing grounds, allow-
ing us to capture how the contribution of human
capital to sheries sustainability differs below and
beyond a threshold value. Furthermore, the human
capital-shing footprint nexus was analyzed for the
rst time within the frameworks of the Environ-
mental Kuznets Curve (EKC) hypothesis and the
Environmental Phillips Curve (EPC) hypothesis
for Greece.
Theoretical framework: schooling and marine
environmental sustainability
Schooling constitutes a core component of hu-
man capital and plays a critical role in shaping
environmental sustainability through multiple
interconnected channels. Unlike income-driven
mechanisms, schooling inuences environmental
outcomes primarily by transforming knowledge,
behavior, institutional capacity, and technological
adaptation (Sapkota and Bastola 2017; Danish et al.
2019). In the context of marine ecosystems, these
channels operate jointly to determine the intensi-
ty and sustainability of shing activities and thus
directly affect the shing footprint (Solarin et al.
2021; Yıldırım et al. 2022).
First, the cognitive-behavioral channel empha-
sizes that higher schooling levels enhance envi-
ronmental literacy, risk perception, and long-term
awareness of resource depletion. More educated
shing communities are more likely to recognize
ecological limits, comply with sheries regulations,
and adopt conservation-oriented behaviors, there-
by reducing pressure on shing grounds (Balaguer
and Cantavella 2018; Çakar et al. 2021). This be-
havioral transformation is particularly relevant for
marine ecosystems, where open-access character-
istics often intensify overexploitation (Yıldırım et
al. 2022; Ayad et al. 2024).
Second, the technological adoption channel
highlights that schooling facilitates the diffusion
and effective use of sustainable shing technolo-
gies, including selective gear, monitoring systems,
and stock assessment tools. These technological
improvements increase efciency while lowering
bycatch, habitat damage, and excessive extraction,
leading to a decline in the shing footprint at higher
schooling levels (Hondroyiannis et al. 2022; Dai et
al. 2024; Teng et al. 2024).
Third, the institutional capacity channel stresses
that schooling strengthens governance quality by
enhancing regulatory enforcement, policy aware-
ness, and stakeholder participation in sheries
management. Higher schooling levels improve the
ability of institutions to design and implement eco-
system-based management strategies, enforce catch
limits, and promote compliance, thereby generating
long-run improvements in marine environmental
quality (Çağlar et al. 2024; Fowler et al. 2023).
This theoretical framework claries that the school-
1Human capital is proxied by schooling, which is commonly adopted in empirical literature (Balaguer and Cantavella 2018; Danish et al.
2019; Ahmed et al. 2020a, 2020b; Khan 2020; Ganda 2022; Ayad 2023; Alsaleh et al. 2024; Dai et al. 2024; Teng et al. 2024).
Marine and Fishery sciences 39 (2): xxx-xxx (2026)
4
Empirical evidence across different environmen-
tal indicators further conrms the heterogeneous
and pollutant-specic impacts of schooling. Saleem
et al. (2019) show that schooling improves some
environmental dimensions while worsening others
in BRICS (Brazil, Russia, India, China, and South
Africa) countries, whereas Zhang et al. (2021) re-
port that schooling reduces CO2 emissions but in-
creases ecological footprint in Pakistan. Similarly,
Hondroyiannis et al. (2022) and Dai et al. (2024)
nd that schooling improves environmental per-
formance in OECD (Organisation for Economic
Co-Operation and Development) and ASEAN (As-
sociation of Southeast Asian Nations) economies,
respectively. These contrasting ndings collectively
indicate that schooling does not exert uniform envi-
ronmental effects and that its inuence depends on
structural, technological, and institutional contexts.
Within the sheries and marine sustainabili-
ty literature, empirical studies remain relatively
limited but increasingly inuential. Alsaleh et al.
(2024) show that schooling signicantly enhanc-
es sheries production in EU14 (the group of 14
pre-2004 European Union member states) coun-
tries, highlighting its productive dimension. Ayad
et al. (2024) and Teng et al. (2024) provide direct
evidence that schooling reduces shing footprint
and improves shing ground load capacity in GCC
(Gulf Cooperation Council) and G20 (the Group of
Twenty major economies) economies, respectively.
Yıldırım et al. (2022) identify nonlinear relation-
ships in Mediterranean countries, showing that low
schooling levels increase shing footprint while
higher schooling levels mitigate environmental
pressure. These ndings collectively conrm that
schooling exerts threshold-dependent effects on
marine ecosystems, reinforcing the relevance of
nonlinear modeling strategies.
Recent marine governance studies further em-
phasize that marine sustainability is shaped by in-
stitutional capacity, technological adaptation, and
governance quality rather than ecological con-
straints alone. Fowler et al. (2023), Elegbede et al.
(2025), and Wang et al. (2025) demonstrate that
ing-shing footprint relationship is not spurious, as
schooling affects sheries sustainability through
behavioral, technological, and institutional mech-
anisms independently of income dynamics (Khan
2020; Chen et al. 2022). Moreover, these channels
imply that the environmental impact of schooling
may be nonlinear: at early stages, schooling can in-
tensify economic activity and resource use, where-
as beyond a certain threshold it fosters sustainable
practices and reduces environmental degradation
(Çakar et al. 2021; Yıldırım et al. 2022).
Literature review
A growing body of research emphasizes that
schooling –widely used as a core proxy for human
capital– is a fundamental determinant of environ-
mental outcomes because it strengthens societies’
capacity to understand ecological risks, adopt
cleaner technologies, and implement sustainable
resource management practices (Sapkota and Bas-
tola 2017; Danish et al. 2019). Environmental qual-
ity is commonly operationalized through indicators
such as ecological footprint, CO2 emissions, and
load capacity factor. However, empirical ndings
consistently reveal that the environmental effects of
schooling are context-dependent, varying across de-
velopment levels, institutional structures, and meth-
odological approaches (Balaguer and Cantavella
2018; Ulucak and Bilgili 2018; Akadiri et al. 2025).
A prominent strand of the literature highlights
that the relationship between schooling and en-
vironmental sustainability is not necessarily lin-
ear. Khan (2020), Chen et al. (2022), and Çakar
et al. (2021) demonstrate that environmental im-
provements often materialize only after schooling
surpasses certain threshold levels, implying the
presence of nonlinear dynamics. These ndings
support the theoretical proposition that early-stage
schooling expansion may intensify production and
resource use, while higher schooling levels foster
technological upgrading, behavioral change, and
institutional strengthening, ultimately reducing en-
vironmental degradation.
Karahan-Dursun et al.: the role of schooling in shaping the fishing footprint in greece 5
integrated management strategies, upstream-down-
stream industrial linkages, and sector-specic mit-
igation policies play decisive roles in determining
environmental pressure on marine systems. These
studies provide a strong conceptual basis for in-
tegrating schooling into sheries sustainability
models.
Beyond schooling, a parallel strand of literature
highlights the importance of structural and socioec-
onomic determinants of shing footprint. Rashdan
et al. (2021), Pata et al. (2023), Yılanci et al. (2023),
and Pata et al. (2024) demonstrate that economic
growth, trade, nancial development, and con-
sumption patterns signicantly shape marine en-
vironmental outcomes. Uzar and Eyüboğlu (2025)
further reveal that income inequality, urbanization,
and unemployment inuence shing footprint dy-
namics, indicating that marine sustainability re-
ects broader macroeconomic and social structures.
Despite these contributions, empirical evidence
directly linking schooling to shing footprint re-
mains scarce for Mediterranean economies. Ex-
isting studies such as Yıldırım et al. (2022), Ayad
(2023), Alsaleh et al. (2024), Ayad et al. (2024),
and Teng et al. (2024) do not analyze Greece,
despite its strong socioeconomic dependence on
sheries and central role in the regional marine
economy. Moreover, no study has investigated
the nonlinear effects of schooling on shing foot-
print or assessed the EKC and EPC hypotheses in
Greece. The present study lls this gap by exam-
ining the threshold-dependent role of schooling in
shaping shing footprint dynamics in Greece over
the period 1990-2022.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Data
For empirical analysis, the Augmented ARDL
(AARDL) over the period 1990-2022 was applied.
The period of the study was based on the availabil-
ity of schooling. Following Yıldırım et al. (2022),
the study tested equations (1) to (6) to examine the
impact of schooling on marine sustainability:
LFFt = α0 + β1LHC + β2LY + β3LY2 + β4LURB + εt (1)
LFFt = α0 + β1LHC + β2LY + β3LY2 + β4LUN + εt (2)
LFFt = α0 + β1LHC + β2LHC2 + β3LY + εt (3)
LFFt = α0 + β1LHC + β2LHC2 + β3LY + β4LURB + εt (4)
LFFt = α0 + β1LHC + β2LHC2 + β3LY + β4LUN + εt (5)
LFFt = α0 + β1LHC + β2LHC2 + β3LY + β4LY2
+ β5LUN + β6LURB + εt (6)
where FF denotes the shing footprint; Y, Y2 are
the real GDP per capita (constant 2015 USD), and
its square, respectively; HC refers to the Human
Development Index measured by the mean years of
schooling; L indicates the natural logarithm; URB
is urban population; and UN expresses the unem-
ployment rate. FF comes from Global Footprint
Network (GFN), while Y, URB, and UN are from
the World Bank. As a human capital indicator, HC
is obtained from the United Nations Development
Program (UNDP). The intercept is α while the
long-run coefcient is β.
Each specication evaluates the inuence of
schooling on the shing footprint. Equations (1),
(2), and (6) also test the validity of the EKC hy-
pothesis within the sheries context. The EKC
hypothesis from the seminal paper by Grossman
and Krueger (1991) suggests the presence of an in-
verted U-shaped relationship between income and
environmental degradation (Balaguer and Canta-
vella 2018). This hypothesis posits that economic
growth initially leads to environmental degradation,
but once income surpasses a certain threshold, fur-
ther growth fosters improvements in environmen-
tal quality. Equations (3), (4), (5), and (6) further
explore potential nonlinearities in the relationship
between schooling and the shing footprint. More-
Marine and Fishery sciences 39 (2): xxx-xxx (2026)
6
over, equations (2), (5) and (6) search the presence
of the EPC framework using shing footprint. The
EPC hypothesis suggests a negative linkage be-
tween unemployment and environmental pollution
(Kashem and Rahman 2020).
Descriptive statistics indicate that variables used
in the analysis display distinct patterns of variabil-
ity, reecting their different structural roles within
the Greek economy (Table 1). The shing footprint
shows moderate dispersion over time, suggesting
meaningful but not abrupt shifts in ecological pres-
sure. Income and human capital remain relative-
ly stable, consistent with gradual economic and
educational dynamics that typically evolve over
longer horizons. Urbanization exhibits minimal
variation, as expected for a mature and structurally
stable urban system. In contrast, unemployment
demonstrates noticeably higher volatility, capturing
Greece’s sensitivity to economic cycles and labor
market uctuations. Overall, statistical properties
of variables conrm that the dataset is well suited
for econometric modeling, with sufcient variabili-
ty to identify both short- and long-run relationships
without indications of extreme outliers or structural
inconsistencies.
The correlation matrix indicates that although
some explanatory variables exhibit moderate as-
sociations, particularly between human capital, ur-
banization, and unemployment, these relationships
do not appear strong enough to suggest serious
multicollinearity concerns (Appendix, Table A1).
Moreover, correlations between the shing foot-
print and regressors remain at manageable levels,
implying that variables capture distinct underlying
dynamics. Overall, the correlation structure does
not signal severe overlap among explanatory vari-
ables, and the model specication is unlikely to be
adversely affected by multicollinearity.
Methodology
Before estimating the long-run relationship be-
tween shing footprint and its socioeconomic de-
terminants, it is necessary to establish the order of
integration of each variable. Unit root testing is a
critical step in the empirical strategy because AR-
DL-type frameworks require that none of the vari-
ables be integrated of order two, while allowing for
a mixture of I(0) and I(1) processes. Conventional
unit root tests such as ADF (Augmented Dick-
ey-Fuller) and PP (Phillips-Perron) often suffer
from size distortions and low power, especially in
small samples, a common feature of environmen-
tal time series covering a limited number of years.
Biased test statistics may lead to incorrect classi-
cations of variables as stationary or non-stationary,
ultimately undermining the validity of subsequent
cointegration inference.
To address these concerns, the analysis employs
the Ng and Perron (2001) unit root test, which im-
proves upon traditional procedures by constructing
modied test statistics (MZa, MZt, MSB, and MPT)
that exhibit superior size and power properties.
These tests incorporate generalized least squares
Table 1. Descriptive statistics.
LFF LY LHC LUN LURB
Mean 2.717700 9.830984 2.268554 2.542996 15.90677
Max 3.091042 10.08471 2.447032 3.320927 15.95891
Min 2.397895 9.640489 2.055789 1.947623 15.80165
Std. dev. 0.224332 0.132984 0.113283 0.396319 0.050293
Obs. 33 33 33 33 33
Karahan-Dursun et al.: the role of schooling in shaping the fishing footprint in greece 7
detrending and an optimally selected lag structure
to mitigate the severe size distortions caused by
excessive differencing and serial correlation. The
Ng-Perron approach therefore provides more reli-
able evidence on the integration properties of the
series, particularly in small samples, and ensures
that the subsequent AARDL estimation is based on
statistically sound pre-testing of stationarity.
The ARDL methodology introduced by Pesaran
et al. (2001) assumes that the dependent variable
is required to be integrated of order 1 (I(1)). Within
this framework, bounds testing procedure involves
conducting an overall F-test on the lagged levels of
all variables and a t-test on the lagged level of the
dependent variable. To address this limitation, Mc-
Nown et al. (2018) introduced an additional F-test
on the lagged levels of the independent variables,
thereby removing the requirement that the depend-
ent variable must necessarily be I(1). This enhance-
ment to the standard ARDL model is termed the
AARDL approach (McNown et al. 2018; Sam et al.
2019). The study adopts the AARDL methodology
and forms equations (7) to (12) for equations (1)
to (6), as follows:
where α0 is the intercept, ɛt is the error component,
Marine and Fishery sciences 39 (2): xxx-xxx (2026)
8
δ represents the long-run effect, and β captures the
short-run effect. Cointegration is conrmed when
the overall F-test on lagged level variables (Foverall),
the t-test on the lagged dependent variable (tDV),
and the F-test on lagged levels of the independent
variable(s) (FIDV) are all rejected. If at least one of
these tests is not rejected, cointegration does not
exist (Sam et al. 2019). The null hypotheses for the
three test statistics for all models (equations 7-12)
are shown below:
i) Foverall test, H0: all δ coefcients on the lagged
level variables = 0.
ii) tDV test, H0: δ1 = 0
iii) FIDV test, H0: all δ coefcients on the lagged
level independent variables = 0.
The exact number of ‘δ’ terms in each null hypoth-
esis depends on the number of regressors included
in the corresponding equation.
RESULTS
The application of the AARDL method requires
that none of the variables are integrated of order
greater than one (Sam et al. 2019). Accordingly, the
empirical analysis started to investigate stationary
properties of the series using the Ng-Perron test
(Table 2).
For the Ng-Perron test, the null hypothesis for
the MZa and MZt statistics suggested that the se-
ries contain a unit root, while the null hypothesis of
the MSB and MPT statistics assumed that the se-
ries were stationary. Results indicated that, in level
forms, the estimated t-statistics for all series were
less than the critical values according to the MZa
and MZt tests, and greater than the critical values
according to the MSB and MPT tests, except for
LURB and LUN (Table 2). Thus, results indicated
that all series except for LURB and LUN were not
stationary at level. The null hypothesis of the MZa
and MZt tests for LURB and LUN was rejected,
whereas the null hypothesis of the MSB and MPT
tests was be rejected, indicating that LURB and
LUN are stationary at 1% signicance level. For
the rst difference of the series, the estimated t
statistics for all series were greater than the critical
values according to MZa and MZt tests and less
than the critical values according to MSB and MPT
tests, except for LURB and LUN. In conclusion,
the Ng-Perron test results indicated that LFF, LHC,
LHC2, LGDP, and LGDP2 were stationary after
differencing [I(1)], whereas LURB and LUN were
integrated of order zero [I(0)].
The AARDL methodology was applied after
conrming that none of the variables in the study
were integrated of order two [I(2)] (Table 3).
Critical values for AARDL cointegration test
were derived from Narayan (2005) (1988, case III)
for the Foverall test, Pesaran et al. (2001) (303, case
III) for the tDV test, and Sam et al. (2019 (134, case
III) for the FIDV test.
Results revealed that calculated Foverall test
statistics exceeded the upper critical value at 1%
signicance level for all equations, while at 5% sig-
nicance level for Equation (3) (Table 4). Likewise,
the null hypothesis for the tDV test statistics, which
evaluates the signicance of the lagged dependent
variable, was rejected at the 1% signicance level
for equations (1) to (5), and 10% signicance lev-
el for equation (6). Lastly, the estimated FIDV test
statistics, which evaluate the lagged values of the
independent variables, were statistically signicant
at 1% signicance level for equations (2), (4), and
(5), at 5% level for equation (1), and at 10% level
for equation (3) and (6). Accordingly, the cointe-
gration test results indicated that the Foverall, tDV
,
and FIDV tests consistently rejected the null of no
cointegration across all specications, i.e. there
was clear evidence of a cointegration relationship
between the shing footprint and the independent
variables in each equation.
After conrming the existence of a cointegra-
tion relationship among the variables, the long-run
AARDL estimation was calculated (Table 4).
For equation (2), human capital affected shing
Karahan-Dursun et al.: the role of schooling in shaping the fishing footprint in greece 9
footprint negatively at 1% signicance level. Ac-
cording to this estimated equation, a 1% increase
in schooling decreased shing footprint by approx-
imately 2.4%. This nding indicated that school-
ing improved marine environmental quality by de-
creasing environmental pollution. Equations (3),
(4), (5), and (6) incorporated the quadratic terms
of human capital to capture its potential non-linear
effects on the shing footprint. Findings from each
of these equations consistently revealed an inverted
U-shaped association between schooling and sh-
ing footprint. These ndings indicated that there
was a threshold level for human capital. Up to this
critical point, schooling exerted a positive effect on
the shing footprint, implying that relatively low
levels of human capital initially increased environ-
mental pressure. Once the threshold was exceeded,
the effect of schooling on the shing footprint be-
came negative.
The estimated coefcients of LGDP and LGDP2
were positive and negative, respectively, and statis-
tically signicant at 1% signicance level in both
equations (1) and (2). This pattern supported the
EKC hypothesis for shing grounds, indicating an
inverted U-shaped relationship between shing
footprint and economic growth. In equations (3)
Table 2. Unit root test results.
Mza MZt MSB MPT
Ng-Perron test
LFF -8.87 -2.106 0.237 10.273
LHC -7.937 -1.981 0.25 11.512
LHC2 -7.019 -1.871 0.267 12.985
LY -6.883 -1.854 0.269 13.239
LY2 -6.999 -1.87 0.267 13.021
LURB -62.994*** -5.482*** 0.087*** 2.027***
LUN -46.158*** -4.743*** 0.103*** 2.278***
ΔLFF -21.753*** -3.275*** 0.151*** 1.206***
ΔLHC -15.415*** -2.736*** 0.178** 1.738***
ΔLHC2 -15.419*** -2.742*** 0.178** 1.719***
ΔLY -12.227** -2.406** 0.197** 2.258**
ΔLY 2 -12.161** -2.398** 0.197** 2.272**
Critical values (level)
1% -23.8 -3.42 0.143 4.03
5% -17.3 -2.91 0.168 5.48
10% -14.2 -2.62 0.185 6.67
Critical values (rst differences)
1% -13.8 -2.58 0.174 1.78
5% -8.1 -1.98 0.233 3.17
10% -5.7 -1.62 0.275 4.45
Note: ∆ denotes the rst-difference operator. *** and ** denote 1% and 5% signicance levels, respectively.
Marine and Fishery sciences 39 (2): xxx-xxx (2026)
10
and (4), economic growth increased the shing foot-
print. In both equations, a 1% increase in economic
growth increased shing footprint by 0.64% in the
long-run. On the other hand, in equation (5), eco-
nomic growth had no signicant effect on shing
footprint.
For equation (1), urban population had a neg-
ative effect on shing footprint. Equation (4)
supported this strong impact of urban population
on shing footprint at 1% signicance level. For
equation (2), unemployment negatively impacted
on shing footprint, conrming the Environmental
Phillips Curve hypothesis. Equations (5) and (6),
which incorporate the exponential forms of human
capital into the model, indicated that the estimat-
ed coefcient of unemployment was negative and
statistically signicant. This nding is consistent
with results of equation (2), which also conrm the
validity of the EPC hypothesis for Greece.
According to the short-run AARDL results (Ta-
ble 5), equations (1), (2), and (3) revealed that
schooling reduces the shing footprint. In equation
(6), the one-period lagged value of human capital
exerted a negative effect on the shing footprint.
On the other hand, equations (4) pointed to a pos-
itive contribution of schooling to environmental
pollution in marine areas.
The positive short-run effect of human capital
on the shing footprint may suggest that initial im-
provements in schooling intensied economic ac-
tivity and resource use, thereby increasing environ-
mental pressure on marine areas. In fact, this result
Table 3. Augmented ARDL cointegration test results.
Test stat. Critical values
Model Foverall tDV FIDV 1% 5% 10%
Equation (1) 8.283*** -5.398*** 5.751** Foverall 6.67 4.774 3.994
tDV -4.6 -3.99 -3.66
F
IDV 6.83 4.7 3.84
Equation (2) 6.802*** -4.696*** 8.386*** Foverall 6.67 4.774 3.994
tDV -4.6 -3.99 -3.66
F
IDV 6.83 4.7 3.84
Equation (3) 6.223** -4.674*** 4.916* Foverall 7.063 5.018 4.15
tDV -4.37 -3.78 -3.46
F
IDV 7.72 5.14 4.11
Equation (4) 8.484*** -5.639*** 8.235*** Foverall 6.67 4.774 3.994
tDV -4.6 -3.99 -3.66
F
IDV 6.83 4.7 3.84
Equation (5) 6.921*** -5.365*** 7.855*** Foverall 6.67 4.774 3.994
tDV -4.6 -3.99 -3.66
F
IDV 6.83 4.7 3.84
Equation (6) 6.182** -4.507* 4.145* Foverall 6.37 4.608 3.858
tDV -4.79 -4.19 -3.86
F
IDV 6.48 4.54 3.76
Note: ***, **, and * denotes 1%, 5%, and 10% signicance level, respectively.
Karahan-Dursun et al.: the role of schooling in shaping the fishing footprint in greece 11
was consistent with the long-run ARDL ndings,
which revealed an inverted U-shaped relationship
between human capital and the shing footprint,
indicating the presence of a threshold effect.
Equations (1) and (6) showed that the EKC
hypothesis is valid for Greece also in the short
run. This nding was consistent with the long-run
AARDL results, further conrming the robustness
of the inverted U-shaped relationship between eco-
nomic growth and the shing footprint. Equation
(4) showed that urban population had a positive in-
uence on shing footprint in the short run, where-
as the opposite holds in the long run. The short run
estimations in equations (2) and (5) showed that
unemployment was negatively associated with the
shing footprint. This result was consistent with
the long run evidence conrming the validity of
the EPC hypothesis.
The error correction term (ECT) reected the
short-term adjustment path. Across all equations
(1) to (6), the ECT coefcients ranged between
-1.224 and -0.936, and were statistically signicant
with the expected sign. With a magnitude between
-1 and -2, the ECT implied that the system did not
converge monotonically to equilibrium. Instead,
the adjustment process oscillated around the long-
run value in a dampened manner before settling
relatively quickly on the equilibrium path (Alam
and Quazi 2003).
The LM, ARCH, Jarque-Bera, and Ramsey RE-
SET tests indicated that the estimated AARDL
models for all equations (1-6) were free from se-
rial correlation, heteroskedasticity, non-normality,
and misspecication problems (Appendix, Table
A2). Besides, the CUSUM and CUSUMQ test re-
sulted for each equation conrmed the reliability
of models.
DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS
Controlling environmental degradation caused
by human activities requires moving beyond
Table 4. Long-run AARDL model results.
Variables Equation (1) Equation (2) Equation (3) Equation (4) Equation (5) Equation (6)
LHC 0.952 -2.362*** 20.854* 52.503*** 52.983*** 57.052**
(-0.699) (-5.692) (1.768) (4.732) (3.945) (2.584)
LHC2 - - -5.507** -11.058*** -11.775*** -12.389**
(-2.189) (-4.827) (-4.118) (-2.717)
LY 152.2383*** 106.967*** 0.644** 0.641** -0.380 121.477*
(3.627) (3.305) (2.722) (2.781) (-0.818) (2.096)
LY2 -7.601*** -5.369*** - - - -6.208*
(-3.582) (-3.27) (-2.103)
LURB -12.672*** - - -8.882*** - 3.678
(-3.088) (-4.504) (0.589)
LUN - -0.252* - - -0.421*** -0.618**
(-1.833) (-3.090) (-2.330)
cons -559.594** -523.78*** -22.372* 75.614*** -51.896*** -717.083**
(-2.849) (-3.290) (-1.759) (-3.264) (-4.481) (-3.507)
Note: ***, **, and * denote 1%, 5%, and 10% signicance levels, respectively. t statistics in parentheses.
Marine and Fishery sciences 39 (2): xxx-xxx (2026)
12
conventional economic indicators and incorpo-
rating broader societal factors such as education,
awareness, and institutional capacity (Ahmed et al.
2020b). The literature offers robust evidence that
human capital plays a pivotal role in shaping en-
vironmental outcomes (Hondroyiannis et al. 2022;
Alsaleh et al. 2024; Çağlar et al. 2024; Çamkaya
and Karaaslan 2024; Teng et al. 2024), while also
demonstrating that its environmental effects may
vary at different stages of human capital accumu-
Table 5. Short-run AARDL model results.
Karahan-Dursun et al.: the role of schooling in shaping the fishing footprint in greece 13
lation (Khan 2020; Chen et al. 2021; Çakar et al.
2021; Yıldırım et al. 2022; Ayad 2023; Akadiri et
al. 2025). Within this context, the present study
contributes to the growing empirical literature
by examining both linear and nonlinear effects of
schooling as an indicator of human capital on the
shing footprint (FF) in Greece over 1990-2022
through the AARDL approach, thereby offering
the rst empirical assessment of the exponential
effects of human capital on marine environmental
degradation for Greece under the EKC and EPC
frameworks.
The long run AARDL results show that higher
levels of schooling reduce the shing footprint in
Eq. (1), conrming that education contributes to
better marine environmental outcomes. This nd-
ing aligns with the broader evidence indicating that
accumulated knowledge and skills promote envi-
ronmental awareness, facilitate compliance with
regulations, support sustainable resource use, and
enhance the adoption of cleaner technologies (Yao
et al. 2020; Hondroyiannis et al. 2022; Çağlar et
al. 2024; Çamkaya and Karaaslan 2024; Dai et al.
2024; Teng et al. 2024). Importantly, the nonlinear
estimates in Eqs. (3) to (6) reveal that human capi-
tal exerts different effects across levels of accumu-
lation: at relatively low levels, increases in school-
ing coincide with higher environmental pressure,
whereas once human capital surpasses a threshold,
it contributes to environmental improvement by
easing the burden on shing grounds. This pattern
is consistent with ndings from Khan (2020), Chen
et al. (2021), and Yıldırım et al. (2022), and reects
a well-known transition mechanism in which early
phases of human capital expansion are associated
with intensied economic activity and resource
extraction, while higher human capital levels
strengthen environmental governance, promote
behavioral change, and facilitate the diffusion of
sustainable practices.
Results also validate the EKC hypothesis for
Greece, indicating that economic growth deterio-
rates environmental quality at earlier stages but im-
proves it once income exceeds a certain threshold.
This is in line with evidence from Pata et al. (2023),
Yılancı et al. (2023), and Ayad et al. (2024), who
similarly conrm the EKC hypothesis in shing
ground contexts. However, for Eqs. (3) and (4),
economic growth has a positive long-run effect
on the shing footprint, supporting the argument
that higher economic activity can intensify pressure
on marine ecosystems, consistent with ndings of
Ganda (2022), Çamkaya and Karaaslan (2024),
and Uzar and Eyüboğlu (2025). Taken together,
these results suggest that the interaction between
economic development and marine environmental
quality is dynamic and context-specic, reinforcing
the need to align economic expansion with sustain-
ability-oriented regulatory frameworks.
Control variables offer additional insights into
marine environmental dynamics. The negative
association between unemployment and environ-
mental degradation conrms the EPC hypothesis
in shing grounds, consistent with the ndings of
Kashem and Rahman (2020), Tariq et al. (2022),
and Şahin et al. (2025). This relationship can be
explained through a labor-resource substitution
mechanism. Periods of rising unemployment are
typically accompanied by contractions in aggregate
economic activity, including reduced market-ori-
ented shing operations, lower industrial-scale
harvesting intensity, and declining seafood pro-
cessing and export demand. In the Greek context,
where commercial shing is highly integrated into
formal markets and regulated value chains, labor
market downturns tend to reduce capital-intensive
shing effort rather than expand subsistence-based
extraction. Consequently, higher unemployment
temporarily alleviates pressure on marine resources,
leading to a measurable reduction in the shing
footprint.
Urban population displays a dual nature: short-
run estimates indicate that rapid urban growth
increases the shing footprint due to immediate
resource demands and waste generation, whereas
long-run estimates show a negative effect, suggest-
ing that improved urban infrastructure, regulatory
enforcement, and greater public awareness even-
Marine and Fishery sciences 39 (2): xxx-xxx (2026)
14
tually mitigate environmental pressure. This tran-
sition is also observed in Yıldırım et al. (2022) for
Mediterranean countries and reects the capacity of
urban centers to evolve into hubs of environmental
governance and technological upgrading.
The ndings have several implications for de-
signing marine sustainability strategies in Greece.
The proven importance of higher levels of school-
ing in reducing the shing footprint highlights the
need to integrate education into environmental and
sheries policies. Strengthening environmental lit-
eracy, embedding sustainability principles in school
curricula, and enhancing public awareness cam-
paigns can promote long-term behavioral change.
Moreover, expanding technical and vocational
training in elds such as sheries management,
marine ecology, and green maritime technologies
can enhance the sectors ability to transition toward
sustainable production systems. Collaboration be-
tween universities, research institutions, and the
private sector could further stimulate innovations
that reconcile ecological protection with econom-
ic productivity. In addition, Greece’s economic
growth strategy should be aligned with the blue
economy framework, prioritizing the safeguarding
of marine resources. Implementing strict environ-
mental standards, enhancing monitoring capacity,
and improving waste management infrastructure,
especially in coastal and port regions, would help
reduce harmful pollutants. In the sheries sector,
establishing scientically based catch quotas, pro-
moting environmentally friendly equipment, and
strengthening ecosystem-based sheries manage-
ment can play a decisive role in preventing resource
depletion. The nding that higher unemployment
temporarily reduces environmental pressure also
suggests the need for employment strategies that
create green jobs and encourage environmentally
responsible economic activity. Likewise, reinforc-
ing the long-term positive effects of urbanization
requires continued investment in green infra-
structure, coastal protection, and efcient waste
management.
Despite its contributions, the study has limi-
tations regarding data availability, sample scope,
and methodological choices. Future research could
incorporate alternative indicators of human capi-
tal and different environmental measures, explore
regional heterogeneity within Greece, and apply
complementary econometric techniques to advance
understanding of the human capital-environment
nexus in marine contexts.
Author contributions
Pınar Karahan-Dursun: investigation; concep-
tualization; formal analysis; methodology; writ-
ing-original draft; writing-review and editing.
Serkan Şengül: investigation; conceptualization;
writing- original draft; writing-review and editing.
Şerif Canbay: investigation; conceptualization;
writing-original draft; writing-review and editing.
REFERENCES
ahmed Z, aSghar mm, malik, mn, nawaZ k.
2020a. Moving towards a sustainable environ-
ment: The dynamic linkage between natural re-
sources, human capital, urbanization, economic
growth, and ecological footprint in China. Re-
sour Policy. 67: 101677. DOI: https://doi.org/10.
1016/j.resourpol.2020.101677
ahmed Z, Zafar mw, ali S. 2020b. Linking ur-
banization, human capital, and the ecological
footprint in G7 countries: an empirical analysis.
Sustain Cities Soc. 55: 102064. DOI: https://doi.
org/10.1016/j.scs.2020.102064
akadiri SS, OZkan O, kirikkaleli d. 2025. Syn-
ergistic impact of renewable energy technology,
governance, digitalisation, and human capital
on sustainable development and load capacity
factor in Germany’s energy landscape. Technol
Soc. 103002. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.te
chsoc.2025.103002
alam i, QuaZi, r. 2003. Determinants of capital
Karahan-Dursun et al.: the role of schooling in shaping the fishing footprint in greece 15
ight: an econometric case study of Bangladesh.
Int Rev Appl Econ. 17 (1): 85-103. DOI: https://
doi.org/10.1080/713673164
alSaleh m, yuan y, lOngQi S. 2024. Do glob-
al competitiveness factors impact the marine
sustainability practices? An empirical evidence
from sheries sector. Bus Strategy Environ. 33
(7): 6671-6688. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/
bse.3839
ayad h. 2023. Investigating the shing grounds
load capacity curve in G7 nations: Evaluating
the inuence of human capital and renewable
energy use. Mar Pollut Bull. 194: 115413. DOI:
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.marpolbul.2023.1154
13
ayad h, ben-Salha O, djellOuli n. 2024. To-
ward maritime sustainability in GCC countries:
What role do economic freedom and human cap-
ital play? Mar Pollut Bull. 206: 116774. DOI:
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.marpolbul.2024.1167
74
balaguer j, Cantavella m. 2018. The role of
education in the Environmental Kuznets Curve.
Evidence from Australian data. Energy Econ.
70: 289-296. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ene-
co.2018.01.021
ben-Salha O, Zmami m. 2024. The impact of hu-
man capital on the load capacity factor in the
middle east and north Africa. Econ Environ. 91
(4): 940-940. DOI: https://doi.org/10.34659/eis.
2024.91.4.940
bigg gr, jiCkellS td, liSS PS, OSbOrn tj.
2003. The role of the oceans in climate. Int J
Climatol. 23 (10): 1127-1159. DOI: https://doi.
org/10.1002/joc.926
Chen y, lee CC, Chen m. 2022. Ecological foot-
print, human capital, and urbanization. Ener-
gy Environ. 33 (3): 487-510. DOI: https://doi.
org/10.1177/0958305X211008610
Çağlar ae, deStek ma, manga m. 2024. An-
alyzing the load capacity curve hypothesis for
the Turkiye: a perspective for the sustainable
environment. J Clean Prod. 444: 141232. DOI:
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2024.141232
ÇaKar nd, gedikli a, erdOğan S, yildirim dÇ.
2021. Exploring the nexus between human cap-
ital and environmental degradation: the case of
EU countries. J Environ Manage. 295: 113057.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvman.2021.11
3057
Çamkaya S, karaaSlan a. 2024. Do renewable
energy and human capital facilitate the
improvement of environmental quality in
the United States? A new perspective on
environmental issues with the load capacity
factor. Environ Sci Pollut Res. 31 (11): 17140-
17155. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11356-02
4-32331-z
dai j, ahmed Z, alvaradO r, ahmad m. 2024.
Assessing the nexus between human capital,
green energy, and load capacity factor: policy-
making for achieving sustainable development
goals. Gondwana Res. 129: 452-464. DOI:
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gr.2023.04.009
daniSh hS, balOCh ma, mahmOOd n. Zhang J.
W. 2019. Linking economic growth and eco-
logical footprint through human capital and bi-
ocapacity. Sustain Cities Soc. 47: 101516. DOI:
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scs.2019.101516
elegbede iO, fakOya ka, adewOlu ma, jOlaO-
ShO tl, adebayO ja, OShOdi e, hungevu rf,
OladOSu aO, abikOye O. 2025. Understanding
the social-ecological systems of non-state sea-
food sustainability scheme in the blue econo-
my. Environ Dev Sustain 27: 2721-2752. DOI:
https://doi.org/10.1007/s10668-023-04004-3
[faO] fOOd and agriCulture OrganiZatiOn Of
the united natiOnS. 2024. The State of world
sheries and aquaculture 2024. Blue transfor-
mation in action. Rome: FAO. DOI: https://doi.
org/10.4060/cd0683en
[faO] fOOd and agriCulture OrganiZatiOn Of
the united natiOnS. 2025. Fishery and aqua-
culture country proles. Greece, 2024. Country
prole fact sheets. In: Fisheries and aquaculture.
Updated Jul 19, 2024. [accessed 2025 Sep 14].
Rome: FAO. https://www.fao.org/shery/en/
facp/GRC?lang=en.
Marine and Fishery sciences 39 (2): xxx-xxx (2026)
16
fOwler am, dOwling na, lyle jm, alóS j, an-
derSOn le, COOke Sj, danylChuk aj, ferter
k, fOlPP h, hutt C, et al. 2023. Toward sus-
tainable harvest strategies for marine sheries
that include recreational shing. Fish Fish. 24:
1003-1019. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/faf.12
781
ganda f. 2022. The environmental impacts of
human capital in the BRICS economies. J
Knowl Econ. 13 (1): 611-634. DOI: https://doi.
org/10.1007/s13132-021-00737-6
[gfn] glObal fOOtPrint netwOrk. 2025. [ac-
cessed 2025 Sep 10]. https://www.footprintnet-
work.org/resources/glossary/#land-area-type.
grOSSman gm, krueger ab. 1991. Environ-
mental impacts of a North American free trade
agreement. NBER Work Pap. 3914: 1-39.
hOndrOyianniS g, PaPaPetrOu e, tSalaPOrta P.
2022. New insights on the contribution of hu-
man capital to environmental degradation: ev-
idence from heterogeneous and cross-correlat-
ed countries. Energy Econ. 116: 106416. DOI:
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eneco.2022.106416
huang C, Zhang X, liu k. 2021. Effects of human
capital structural evolution on carbon emissions
intensity in China: a dual perspective of spatial
heterogeneity and nonlinear linkages. Renew-
able Sustainable Energy Rev. 135: 110258. DOI:
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rser.2020.110258
kaShem ma, rahman mm. 2020. Environmental
Phillips curve: OECD and Asian NICs perspec-
tive. Environ Sci Pollut Res. 27 (25): 31153-
31170. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11356-02
0-08620-8
khan m. 2020. CO2 emissions and sustainable
economic development: new evidence on the
role of human capital. Sustainable Dev. 28
(5): 1279-1288. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/
sd.2083
landrigan Pj, Stegeman jj, fleming le, al-
lemand d, anderSOn dm, baCker lC,
bruCker-daviS f, Chevalier n, COrra l, et
al. 2020. Human health and ocean pollution.
Ann Glob Health. 86 (1): 151. DOI: https://doi.
org/10.5334/aogh.2831
mCnOwn r, Sam Cy, gOh Sk. 2018. Bootstrapping
the autoregressive distributed lag test for coin-
tegration. Applied Econ. 50 (13): 1509-1521.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/00036846.2017.13
66643
narayan Pk. 2005. The saving and investment
nexus for China: evidence from cointegration
tests. Appl Econ. 37 (17): 1979-1990. DOI:
https://doi.org/10.1080/00036840500278103
ng S, PerrOn P. 2001. Lag length selection and
the construction of unit root tests with good size
and power. Econometrica. 69 (6): 1519-1554.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/1468-0262.00256
Pata uk, erdOgan S, SOlarin Sa, OkumuS i.
2024. Evaluating the inuence of democracy,
nancial development, and shery product
consumption on shing grounds: A case study
for Malaysia. Mar Policy. 168: 106301. DOI:
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.marpol.2024.106301
Pata uk, kartal mt, adali Z, karlilar S. 2023.
Proposal of shing load capacity curve and test-
ing validity: evidence from top 20 countries
with highest sheries production by panel data
approaches. Ocean Coast Manage. 245: 106856.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ocecoaman.2023.
106856
PeSaran mh, Shin y, Smith rj. 2001. Bounds
testing approaches to the analysis of level re-
lationships. J Appl Econometrics. 16: 289-326.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/jae.616
raShdan mOj, faiSal f, turSOy t, PervaiZ r.
2021. Investigating the N-shape EKC using
capture sheries as a biodiversity indicator:
empirical evidence from selected 14 emerg-
ing countries. Environ Sci Pollut Res. 28 (27):
36344-36353. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11
356-021-13156-6
Saleem n, Shujah-ur-rahman jZ. 2019. The
impact of human capital and biocapacity on
environment: environmental quality measure
through ecological footprint and greenhouse
gases. J Pollut Effects Control. 7 (2): 237.
Sam Cy, mCnOwn r, gOh Sk. 2019. An augment-
Karahan-Dursun et al.: the role of schooling in shaping the fishing footprint in greece 17
ed autoregressive distributed lag bounds test for
cointegration. Econ Model. 80: 130-141. DOI:
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.econmod.2018.11.001
SaPkOta P, baStOla u. 2017. Foreign direct in-
vestment, income, and environmental pollution
in developing countries: panel data analysis of
Latin America. Energy Econ. 64: 206-212. DOI:
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.eneco.2017.04.001
SOlarin Sa, gil-alana la, lafuente C. 2021.
Persistence and sustainability of shing grounds
footprint: evidence from 89 countries. Sci Total
Environ. 751: 141594. DOI: https://doi.org/10.
1016/j.scitotenv.2020.141594
Şahin g, naimOglu m, kavaZ i, Sahin, a. 2025.
Examining the environmental Phillips curve
hypothesis in the ten most polluting emerging
economies: economic dynamics and sustain-
ability. Sustainability. 17 (3): 920. DOI: https://
doi.org/10.3390/su17030920
tariQ S, mehmOOd u, ul haQ Z, mariam a. 2022.
Exploring the existence of environmental Phil-
lips curve in South Asian countries. Environ Sci
Pollut Res. 29 (23): 35396-35407. DOI: https://
doi.org/10.1007/s11356-021-18099-6
teng f, mehmOOd u, alOfaySan h, Sun y. 2024.
Bridging shores: leveraging green nance, -
nancial globalization, and human capital for a
cleaner environment in G-20 marine ecosys-
tems using the shing ground capability curve
theory. Mar Policy. 170: 106354. DOI: https://
doi.org/10.1016/j.marpol.2024.106354
uluCak r, bilgili f. 2018. A reinvestigation of
EKC model by ecological footprint measure-
ment for high, middle and low income countries.
J Clean Prod. 188: 144-157. DOI: https://doi.
org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2018.03.191
[un] united natiOnS. 2025. The Sustainable de-
velopment goals report 2025. New York: UN.
51 p.
[undP] united natiOnS develOPment PrO-
gramme. 2025. Human development reports.
[accessed 2025 Aug 5]. https://hdr.undp.org/
data-center/documentation-and-downloads.
uZar u, eyubOglu k. 2025. The role of income
inequality in shaping shing ground footprint in
Indonesia: insights from the fourier augmented
ARDL approach. Mar Policy. 176: 106635. DOI:
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.marpol.2025.106635
wang C, liu X, li k, wei C, Xie m. 2025. In-
ter-sectoral dynamics of the global sheries
carbon footprint: a multi-regional input-output
analysis within the principle of common but dif-
ferentiated responsibilities. Front Mar Sci. 12:
1563747. DOI: https://doi.org/10.3389/fmars.
2025.1563747
wOrld bank. 2025. World development indicators.
[accessed 2025 Aug 5]. https://databank.world-
bank.org/source/world-development-indicators.
yaO y, ivanOvSki k, inekwe j, Smyth r. 2020.
Human capital and CO2 emissions in the long
run. Energy Econ. 91: 104907. DOI: https://doi.
org/10.1016/j.eneco.2020.104907
yilanCi v, CutCu i, Cayir b, Saglam mS. 2023.
Pollution haven or pollution halo in the shing
footprint: Evidence from Indonesia. Mar Pollut
Bull. 188: 114626. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/
j.marpolbul.2023.114626
yildirim dÇ, yildirim S, bOStanCi Sh, turan t.
2022. The nexus between human development
and shing footprint among Mediterranean
countries. Mar Pollut Bull. 176: 113426. DOI:
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.marpolbul.2022.11342
6
Zhang l, gOdil di, bibi m, khan mk, Sarwat
S, anSer mk. 2021. Caring for the environ-
ment: How human capital, natural resources,
and economic growth interact with environmen-
tal degradation in Pakistan? A dynamic ARDL
approach. Sci Total Environ. 774: 145553. DOI:
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2021.145553
Marine and Fishery sciences 39 (2): xxx-xxx (2026)
18
APPENDIX
Table A1. Correlation matrix.
LFF LY LHC LUN LURB
LFF 1 0.135 -0.611 -0.746 -0.551
LY 0.135 1 0.578 -0.092 0.642
LHC -0.611 0.578 1 0.632 0.761
LUN -0.746 -0.092 0.632 1 0.659
LURB -0.551 0.642 0.761 0.659 1
Table A2. Diagnostic test results.
Diagnostic tests Equation (1) Equation (2) Equation (3) Equation (4) Equation (5) Equation (6)
LM test (Breusch 0.757 1.236 0.443 0.443 0.072 0.831
-Godfrey) (0.400) (0.315) (0.649) (0.649) (0.931) (0.456)
Heteroscedasticity test 0.002 1.788 0.069 0.087 0.089 1.298
(ARCH) (0.988) (0.132) (0.933) (0.769) (0.767) (0.290)
Jarque-Bera Normality 0.503 1.439 0.059 0.039 0.217 0.247
test (0.777) (0.487) (0.971) (0.981) (0.897) (0.884)
Ramsey reset test 0.198 0.913 0.97 0.787 1.067 1.579
(0.846) (0.42) (0.399) (0.439) (0.361) (0.241)
CUSUM Stable
CUSUMQ Stable
Note: p values in parentheses.